Exploring Leadership Styles in Nursery Management
Strong leadership is vital in any organisation, but it’s especially important in nursery and childcare management. Leaders set the direction, inspire their teams, and create a supportive environment that encourages communication and collaboration.
Our recent survey, A Look into Early Years Staff Wellbeing, revealed some interesting differences in how nursery practitioners and leaders view their roles, expectations and perceptions. It also showed that working in early childhood education brings high levels of job satisfaction, due to it being a rewarding career. Those who work in early years education are often passionate about what they do, prioritising the needs of children above their own. There are several leadership roles in a typical nursery, including nursery owners, managers, deputy managers, and even third-in-charge positions, depending on the nursery’s size. Other roles may include admin managers, operations managers, and room leaders.
You might notice varied ways of leading with so many different leaders in one setting. Each leadership style is unique, just like every individual. Understanding each leader’s style is key to working better together and understanding the reasoning behind their decision-making. When leaders unite as a cohesive team, it creates a supportive atmosphere where apprentices, practitioners, and all staff members feel encouraged and inspired to advance in their careers. This is the “trickle-down effect” of effective leadership.
In this blog, we’ll explore various leadership styles in nursery management and how you can use them to promote a happy team and positive wellbeing.
Why is effective leadership important in nurseries
Effective leadership is essential in nursery settings as it creates a positive environment where children, staff, and families grow and succeed. Strong leadership brings clear guidance, encouragement, and support, which in turn improves how a nursery functions daily.
For staff, good leadership boosts morale and increases teamwork. When nursery leaders are supportive and approachable, staff feel more valued and motivated, making it easier to work together to provide the best care. This happy and collaborative atmosphere directly benefits children, as engaged and motivated staff create nurturing and stimulating environments that support early development and learning.
From a child’s perspective, the quality of nursery leadership impacts their overall experience. Skilled leaders ensure that staff follow best practices, plan enriching activities, and focus on each child’s unique needs, helping children grow socially, emotionally, and academically.
Finally, effective leadership plays a key role in a nursery’s long-term success. It builds trust with parents and caregivers, assures high-quality standards, and promotes a welcoming and safe environment. With strong leadership, nurseries can grow and maintain a well-deserved reputation for excellence in early years care and education.
Understanding different leadership styles
Understanding different leadership styles is essential in nurseries, as each approach has its own influence on staff dynamics, communication, and the overall environment. Here’s a look at some common leadership styles and how they can benefit (or challenge) nursery settings.
1. Democratic leadership
In a democratic leadership style, leaders value the input of team members, encouraging open communication and shared decision-making.
Benefits: democratic leaders champion collaboration and make staff feel heard and valued, which can increase motivation and job satisfaction. This style can lead to a strong sense of unity and shared goals within the nursery.
Drawbacks: decision-making may be slower as it relies on group consensus, which may not be suitable when quick responses are needed. If not managed well, too many opinions can sometimes create confusion or indecision.
2. Authoritarian leadership
Authoritarian leaders make decisions independently, providing clear instructions and expecting staff to follow them closely.
Benefits: this style can be useful in situations that require structure, consistency, and quick decision-making. It helps establish clear boundaries and can provide a sense of order, which may benefit nurseries needing a firm hand to maintain standards.
Drawbacks: staff may feel limited or undervalued as there is little room for individual input. Over time, this can reduce motivation and increase stress, as team members may feel they’re not trusted to make decisions on their own.
3. Transformational leadership
Transformational leaders focus on inspiring and motivating their team, often aiming for growth and positive change. They set high expectations and encourage staff to develop and innovate.
Benefits: transformational leaders create an enthusiastic, forward-thinking environment. Staff feel inspired to reach their full potential, and this can positively impact creativity in lesson planning and care strategies.
Drawbacks: high expectations and a constant focus on improvement can sometimes feel overwhelming for team members, especially in the demanding nursery setting. Without proper support, staff may experience burnout.
4. Laissez-faire leadership
Laissez-faire leaders take a hands-off approach, giving staff considerable autonomy and only stepping in when necessary.
Benefits: this style can work well with experienced, self-motivated teams who enjoy the freedom to make decisions. It creates a relaxed environment where staff feel trusted and empowered.
Drawbacks: without regular guidance, there’s a risk of inconsistent practices. Less experienced staff may feel unsupported, which can lead to a lack of cohesion and unclear standards within the nursery.
Building a unified leadership team in nurseries
Creating a unified leadership team in a nursery setting is important in providing consistent care, building a positive atmosphere, and achieving the nursery’s goals. While each leader may bring a unique style, working together effectively can transform these differences into strengths. Here are some practical tips to help nursery leaders collaborate successfully:
Take a leadership style test
One effective way to understand each other’s strengths and approaches is by taking a leadership style test as a team. This can reveal each leader’s natural style and give everyone insight into how each person prefers to communicate, make decisions, and solve problems. By knowing each other’s styles, the team can better understand each leader’s approach and use this knowledge to their advantage. For instance, a transformational leader may be great at inspiring staff during team meetings, while a democratic leader might excel at encouraging collaboration on new ideas.
Establish a shared vision and common goals
Aligning on a shared vision for the nursery’s core values and objectives helps unite leaders with differing styles. This vision could focus on child development, quality care, or staff wellbeing. By setting common goals, leaders can work towards a mutual mission, respecting each other’s strengths while keeping the nursery’s needs at the forefront.
Schedule regular leadership meetings
Regular meetings allow leaders to discuss priorities, progress, and challenges, ensuring everyone is aligned. These sessions also encourage proactive problem-solving and give each leader a space to share their perspective. Holding consistent meetings builds trust and reinforces a unified team approach.
Clear communication is essential in any successful team. And regular meetings allow leaders to communicate openly, respecting each other’s perspectives. This ensures that everyone stays informed without information overload and that any differences in leadership style don’t create misunderstandings.
Leverage each leader’s strengths
Understanding each leader’s strengths allows the team to play to these when tackling tasks or addressing challenges. For example, an authoritarian leader might be best for enforcing nursery policies, while a democratic leader could be valuable in team discussions. By recognising each style’s strengths, the team can create a balanced approach that makes the most of everyone’s skills.
How leadership supports staff development
Strong leadership in nurseries is important for supporting staff wellbeing and encouraging professional growth. Leaders who prioritise mentoring, offer regular training, and provide constructive feedback create an environment where staff feel valued and motivated. Mentoring allows experienced leaders to share insights, helping staff build confidence and skills in their roles. Regular training keeps the team up-to-date with best practices, whether in child development, behaviour management, or safeguarding, ensuring high standards of care and providing staff with new, engaging opportunities to grow.
Supporting staff wellbeing is equally important. Leaders who recognise hard work, offer emotional support, and promote work-life balance help reduce burnout and build trust. Regular feedback, celebrating achievements, and offering mental health resources create a culture of respect and appreciation. This investment in staff development and wellbeing not only strengthens team morale but also improves the overall quality of care, creating a nurturing and positive nursery environment where both children and staff can learn and develop.
If you enjoyed this topic, take a look at our blog post by Heidi Wright, Nursery Manager at Brook Farm Children’s Nursery: 10 Tips for Mastering Early Years Nursery Leadership.
We’ve also collaborated with early years expert Jamie Victoria, known as The Childcare Guru, in another insightful post where she explores leadership and management in the EYFS. Happy reading!
Download our FREE report and register for our webinar!
Use the button below to pre-register for our free downloadable report and webinar featuring The Childcare Guru!
Share this article
About the Author
Content Marketing Executive at Connect Childcare